tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post1727798742408452712..comments2023-06-25T17:10:00.793+08:00Comments on Roman Polanski: The Ballad of Contradictions: Reply to Leigh's Comment (Chapter 2. Rape?)Jeanhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/06083598595101518329noreply@blogger.comBlogger8125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-17307343312268682012015-07-26T16:45:37.479+08:002015-07-26T16:45:37.479+08:00To Leigh:
1) It totally stands to reason that it ...To Leigh:<br /><br />1) It totally stands to reason that it is impossible to tell how frightened someone is only by looking at them. That's why the fact of how she looked isn't the ONLY thing contended to be out of keeping with the fright card, but merely one of many different pieces that corroborate and, taken together, make it highly implausible (one hesitates to say outright impossible) that she would have felt any fear whatsoever in given circumstances.<br /><br />2) They were not alone. There was another woman in the house, of whom Samantha was well aware. (Another piece that undermines the fear assertion).<br /><br />3) Samantha herself has said many years later that she knew she could have stopped the intercourse at any time if she had wanted, but that she let it go. That's as close as it can get from her tongue to an admission that there indeed was no fear involved.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-58194060304462496162013-01-18T00:44:07.205+09:002013-01-18T00:44:07.205+09:00My point is that you cannot tell how frightened so...My point is that you cannot tell how frightened someone is by looking at them, plenty of young models are sent on jobs alone it doesn't prove their parents are trying to set anything up and its easy to see why a 13 year old - virgin or not - would be afraid being alone with a man in his 40's who is trying to have sex with her.Leighnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-51135041786592374112011-09-02T21:51:31.827+09:002011-09-02T21:51:31.827+09:00Это мне напомнило одну фразу из известного фильма:...Это мне напомнило одну фразу из известного фильма:Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-37606695989798663162011-08-14T20:15:00.712+09:002011-08-14T20:15:00.712+09:00I think this is one of the most important informat...I think this is one of the most important information for me. And i am glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, The website style is perfect, the articles is really niceAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-5416951484139450862011-04-29T17:55:44.495+09:002011-04-29T17:55:44.495+09:00To Elena: while she is sitting on a couch with her...To Elena: while she is sitting on a couch with her panties on? Some actions would have had to be undertaken. <br /><br />To Leigh:<br /><br />Sorry Leigh… what was it all about? How is all of this relevant to our conversation, or to anything else? I won’t even point out the contradictions in your statements (though now, just like Geimer, you’ve started to contradict yourself, not only the documented facts), since at the moment I totally fail to see the point you are trying to make.<br /><br />Once again I have to repeat that there are only two types of fact in this case: the ones that work for the defense conclusively, and the ones that do so inconclusively. There are no known facts or evidence that would work for the prosecution.Jeanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06083598595101518329noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-89614264092180480202011-04-28T06:58:47.686+09:002011-04-28T06:58:47.686+09:00If you touch someones vagina with your tongue you ...If you touch someones vagina with your tongue you are performing cunnilingus therefore if she had her legs together he could still perform oral on her as he could touch parts of her vagina.Elenanoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-23432277947921798012011-04-28T02:27:29.877+09:002011-04-28T02:27:29.877+09:00Polanski was charged with Unlawful Sexual Intercou...Polanski was charged with Unlawful Sexual Intercourse as part of a plea bargain.<br /><br />The fact she didn't seem scared doesn't prove anything. There was a woman called Debbie Morris who was kidnapped and raped and wrote the book about it called Forgiving the Dead Man Walking. Many people saw her during her kidnap and not one person thought she looked scared and they assumed she was the kidnappers girlfriend. There is no one way to respond to sexual assault and you can't tell how someone is feeling on the inside.<br /><br />When Kate Moss was 14 she was sent off alone with fashion photographers one of whom turned out to be sex offender. Katie Price was molested by a photographer while unaccompanied at a modeling shoot when she was young. Do you assume their parents set it up to entrap the photographers as well.<br /><br />Also Samantha said she had sex with her teenage boyfriend once or twice. Do you have any proof she had more experience than that?Leighnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4186171714707843344.post-37858459236107641962011-04-28T02:14:02.042+09:002011-04-28T02:14:02.042+09:00Lots of stupid kids do drugs, drink and have sex. ...Lots of stupid kids do drugs, drink and have sex. It doesn't mean they can't be the victim of a crime - neither does being uninhibited - and it doesn't mean that wouldn't be afraid if an adult made a pass at them and ignored them when they told them to stop. We do indeed have our own psychologies which is why we can't claim to know how Samantha would have felt. Whether she had reason to be afraid of him before what happened doesn't matter because he had not broken the law then. I can see why she would have been afraid if she told him no and he ignored her and she might have gone along with it out of fear but that does not equal consent.<br /><br />I don't claim to know that he raped her. I don't think it was proven he raped her but I don't think you have proven she is a liar either.Leighnoreply@blogger.com